|
|
Post by Persephone on Aug 5, 2004 10:16:36 GMT 10
OK, I give her that she has a good voice, but I can't help but feel Chanel is kind of false. The hair, clothes, that last audition with all the guys on stage (which I'm sorry, but did not have a single element of originality to me) it all seems contrived. She seems like a poser and putting on a big act to hypnotise the judges (which she is succeeding at). Anyhow, looks like she has an excellent chance of making it through to the final 12, so I just hope she has the substance (that she doesn't have yet or is hiding really well) to prove me wrong!  |
|
4213
New Member
Posts: 89
|
Post by 4213 on Aug 5, 2004 13:57:30 GMT 10
I saw her trying to support the girl who forgot her words. She is genuinely warm. A fake couldn't pretend that. She is flamboyant, yes. You only get one chance, you have to stand out. The judges haven't helped her, she would be feeling unnerved by their approach.
I find her interesting, at least she has character.
A real example of fake is that Jasmine, with the mini skirt. Out for number 1, like her mate Millsy. Zero class. I should substantiate this by saying I felt she didn't help her group at all and was very focused on just her. This selfishness grates with me. I feel the people with warm hearts deserve to prosper.
|
|
spirit
New Member
I think to myself......What a Wonderful World
Posts: 157
|
Post by spirit on Aug 5, 2004 15:02:27 GMT 10
The fact that the judges are praising Chanel so highly would be more of a hinderance at the moment. I don't think she is a fake - just someone who's very individual both in her appearance and her approach. We need to have a final 12 who are different and individual, not a load of clones.
Chanel has been one of those that the show has been more focussed on so far which is why more people have formed opinions of her - but from Sunday we really get to see and hear them all a bit more equally.
|
|
ktj
New Member
Posts: 51
|
Post by ktj on Aug 5, 2004 15:07:40 GMT 10
I think she's fantastic to. Maybe you think she's fake because she is getting praise and not negative remarks. She's unique and different, this I think is a great thing to have on Idol. Like Axl from last year, so many people loved him because he offered different unique performances compared to the others, now he's hosting Video Hits - GO CHANEL!
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathy on Aug 5, 2004 20:34:31 GMT 10
Chanel is fantastic. There is nothing wrong with her.
She's taking chances, playing up to all her strengths and is being genuine. She is having fun, and is a true individual. She is making the viewers and judges stand up and take notice. Kudos to her.
She's beautiful, original, and sweet. I sincerely hope she wins.
Mwah girls. MRRRRROW Love Roy.
Hahaha
|
|
|
|
Post by Belle on Aug 5, 2004 20:44:52 GMT 10
She rocks my world and is obviously very genuine- where on earth are you getting fake from? And such a cutie!!!
Cheers to the breathe of fresh air she'll hopefully bring to the Australian music industry...
She truly is the only reason I'm watching the show.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mikey on Aug 5, 2004 20:52:47 GMT 10
chanel is the best, i love her, i hope she wins, she's so cool, beautiful, cute, and has a great voice and personality, persephone, ur wrong
|
|
|
|
Post by ChanelAdmirer on Aug 5, 2004 21:27:11 GMT 10
Persephone you're the one who's fake.  Sitting behind a computer, typing out harsh and hurtful criticisms without thinking about Chanel reading this. GO out and DO something MEANINGFUL in your life and keep thoughs USELESS comments to YOURSELF. |
|
teetree
New Member
I'm sneezy because of my surname
Posts: 2,904
|
Post by teetree on Aug 5, 2004 21:34:23 GMT 10
the judges see her as different because she has a personality that stands herself out from the crowd. Australian idol isn't just looking for a great voice, they're looking for a great personality as well, and Chanel has both of those qualities
|
|
|
|
Post by Magnolia on Aug 5, 2004 21:57:25 GMT 10
There are many people out there who feel threatened by anyone who dares be different... How absolutely refreshing is it to see someone like Chanel, and Billie too for that matter, not belt out some shrilling over-sung over-performed song and produce a beautiful, original and individual performance?
We need more champions like you two in the public eye!
|
|
|
|
Post by Billie on Aug 5, 2004 22:27:04 GMT 10
she's not fake
and thankyou
|
|
|
|
Post by Miss s on Aug 5, 2004 22:30:36 GMT 10
OK, I give her that she has a good voice, but I can't help but feel Chanel is kind of false. The hair, clothes, that last audition with all the guys on stage (which I'm sorry, but did not have a single element of originality to me) it all seems contrived. She seems like a poser and putting on a big act to hypnotise the judges (which she is succeeding at). Anyhow, looks like she has an excellent chance of making it through to the final 12, so I just hope she has the substance (that she doesn't have yet or is hiding really well) to prove me wrong! I vomit on this statement. Chanel has so much charactor, I think she's great, and very beautiful. Love Miss S |
|
|
|
Post by Amali on Aug 5, 2004 23:12:55 GMT 10
I like her. She's genuinely nice.
|
|
|
|
Post by GOGO on Aug 5, 2004 23:28:13 GMT 10
I think that Chanel is fantastic. She is out there showing people that she has talent and good on her. What I saw in the television was a warm talented funny wonderful girl who gives 100% to whatever she does. So get rid of the negative attitude Persephone. One thing is for sure Chanel has got more guts than you have.
|
|
invisable angels roam always
Guest
|
Post by invisable angels roam always on Aug 6, 2004 1:17:14 GMT 10
i love Chanel and Billie, they are both such unique people, they prove that you dont have to have a super powerful vioce like paulini to make the top 30 or even 12 (i'm really hoping they make it through)
They have their own style and they shouldn't ever be put down for it.......................its disheartening to know that the minute someone stands up and doesn't walk in a straight line like all the others they are shot down for it!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chanel and Billie your uniqueness is your strong point NOT a negative.......others will always have their opinons but just leave it at that- its just an opinion doesn't mean its the only or right one.
rise above it all, beautiful girls, my opinion is your wonderful performers
|
|
